Economic Observer Follow
2026-11-19 19:19

Economic Observer reporter Tian Guobao
In early November 2026, Wanwu Cloud announced that it had signed 191 debt repayment agreements with Vanke. Vanke and its affiliates plan to offset approximately RMB 659 million in overdue debts with assets such as residential properties, parking spaces, shops, apartments, and office buildings.
At the end of October, Zhongjun Commercial Management and Sunac Services successively disclosed the arrangement of related parties using assets to offset debts. Zhongjun Commercial Management plans to acquire equity in the project companies of three Zhongjun World Cities, offsetting most of the acquisition price with the principal and interest of the receivable loans. Rongchuang Service plans to take over real estate and parking spaces in Harbin, Guangzhou and other places to offset the service fees owed by the relevant project companies.
There are a large number of related transactions between real estate companies and their affiliated property companies on a daily basis. Prior to 2021, the main transactions were between real estate companies and their affiliated property companies; After 2021, some developers have reduced their sales receipts and tightened their financing channels, resulting in a large amount of receivables and debts between the two.
A private property company insider told the Economic Observer that the property company originally had low profits, and the accounts receivable and debts between the property company and its affiliated real estate companies could not be recovered, resulting in enormous pressure on the property company. Some property management companies are independent listed companies and are responsible for the interests of small and medium-sized shareholders.
In his opinion, most of the debts owed by real estate companies to affiliated property companies are absorbed in the form of provisions, and the proportion of debt offset by assets is relatively small. Moreover, most of the debt repayment assets are unsold assets with low operating value, and it is difficult for property companies to realize them after taking over, but having them is better than not having them.
Using assets to offset debts
The debt assets disclosed by Wanwu Cloud are distributed in cities such as Shanghai, Shenzhen, Chengdu, Wuhan, Zhengzhou, Shenyang, and Qingdao. Among them, the three office buildings in Chengdu Tianfu Vanke Cloud City have a total construction area of about 2228 square meters and a valuation of about 30.02 million yuan; The total construction area of 35 apartments in Xi'an is approximately 3552 square meters, priced at approximately 24.96 million yuan.
In December 2024 and July 2025, Wanwu Cloud disclosed that it had signed debt repayment agreements with Vanke for approximately 703 million yuan and 257 million yuan respectively.
According to the interim report of Wanwu Cloud, as of the end of June 2026, its trade and margin receivables from Vanke Group and its affiliated and joint ventures amounted to approximately 1.774 billion yuan, a year-on-year decrease of approximately 14.1%.
Unlike Wanwu Cloud, which receives dispersed real estate assets, Zhongjun Commercial Management's transactions involve three complete commercial projects.
According to the announcement on October 27th, Zhongjun Commercial Management plans to acquire the equity of project companies in three Zhongjun World Cities, namely Shuitou in Nan'an, Fujian, Pingdingshan in Henan, and Xianyou in Putian, Fujian, for 1.06 billion yuan. As of August 31, 2026, the total valuation of the three assets is approximately 1.096 billion yuan, and the transaction price is approximately 35.5 million yuan lower than the valuation.
In November 2022, a subsidiary of Zhongjun Commercial Management provided a maximum loan of 900 million yuan to related enterprises of Zhongjun Group, with an initial agreed annual interest rate of 7%. In November 2024, both parties agreed to extend the expiration date from the end of 2024 to the end of 2026. As of August 31, 2026, the outstanding principal and interest of loans amounted to approximately 908.4 million yuan.
According to the transaction plan, Zhongjun Commercial Management will offset part of the acquisition price with this related debt, and the remaining approximately RMB 151.6 million will be paid in cash. After the transaction is completed, Zhongjun Commercial Management will acquire equity in three project companies, and the operating performance of the three commercial projects will also be included in its financial statements.
The advantage of Zhongjun Commercial Management taking over commercial heavy assets is that after the integration of light and heavy assets, there is a possibility of monetization through the issuance of public REITs in the future; Unfortunately, the total net profit of the three commercial projects in 2024 and 2025 will suffer losses of approximately 52 million yuan and 54 million yuan respectively.
On October 30th, Sunac Services disclosed five new debt repayment agreements, involving two sets of commercial housing in Harbin, 20 parking spaces in Guangzhou, and properties in Wenzhou, Shijiazhuang, Wuhan, and other places. The total transaction price was approximately 15.45 million yuan, which was used to offset the service fees owed by Sunac China.
In June 2025, Rongwanjia and Rongsheng Development signed a new round of debt repayment framework agreement, intending to receive 12689 parking spaces, 5479 storage rooms, and 112 residential, apartment, and commercial properties for approximately 1.07 billion yuan to offset service and project payments.
From the above transactions, it can be seen that real estate companies are using assets to repay property company debts, gradually expanding their scope from residential and parking spaces to commercial and operational assets.
The above-mentioned property management personnel stated that most property companies have poor asset management and operational capabilities. Taking over operational assets was originally an opportunity for property companies to improve their corresponding capabilities, but due to the generally poor quality of debt assets, it is difficult to use them as operational assets, and more need to be sold for cash.
Where does the debt come from
Around 2015, the scale of real estate development expanded, and property management gradually became an independent business sector for real estate companies. When a developer sells a new house, the affiliated property management company is responsible for site management, customer reception, and early intervention. After delivery, the property management company takes over daily management and facility maintenance, and expands the scale of management through related projects.
Poly Property disclosed in the early stage of its listing that from 2019 to 2021, the annual upper limits for related party transactions under non owner value-added services were RMB 868 million, RMB 1.041 billion, and RMB 1.25 billion, respectively, involving business such as case sales coordination. In 2020, Shimao Services, Sunac Services, Evergrande Property, and others went public successively, and the business from affiliated developers remains the source of income for property companies.
After 2021, some developers have slowed down their sales receipts and started to postpone payment of service fees and project payments. The recognized revenue has accumulated into accounts receivable.
A research report released by Guotai Haitong Securities in 2025 shows that the accounts receivable of 30 sample listed property companies increased from 29.18 billion yuan at the end of 2020 to 68.34 billion yuan at the end of 2022, a two-year growth of about 134%.
As of the end of 2025, the total book value of trade receivables generated from services provided by Ya Life to relevant entities of Yajule Group is approximately 3.527 billion yuan, a decrease of approximately 46 million yuan from the end of 2024. Ya Life's expected credit loss provision for this portion of accounts receivable is approximately 3.161 billion yuan, accounting for 89.62% of the total book value.
From 2024 to the first half of 2026, the net impairment loss of financial assets of Ya Life amounted to nearly 5 billion yuan, with the majority of it being impairment of trade receivables.
In addition to service fees and project payments, some property management companies also have funds directly lent to developers. In July 2022, Jinko Services provided a loan of 1.5 billion yuan to Jinko Real Estate, with an agreed annual interest rate of 8.6%. Jinko Real Estate failed to repay as agreed. In March 2024, the First Intermediate People's Court of Chongqing issued a civil mediation agreement to confirm the relevant debt obligations.
Jinke Services applies for compulsory enforcement, intending to recover outstanding debts through judicial auctions and receiving unsold assets, involving 17935 parking spaces and 6 commercial property projects, with a total assessed value of approximately 1.059 billion yuan. After Jinko Real Estate entered the bankruptcy reorganization process, the relevant debts were transferred to the reorganization process.
According to the announcement from Jinko Services, as of the end of June 2025, the total accounts receivable of this loan is approximately 1.659 billion yuan, with a provision for impairment of approximately 1.354 billion yuan and a net book value of approximately 305 million yuan. On April 28, 2026, Jinko Corporation disclosed that it had confirmed with Jinko Services that the debt had been repaid according to the restructuring plan.
Jinko Corporation disclosed in its 2026 interim report that as of the end of June, based on the overall restructuring of debt, the cash redemption completion rate was 71.36%, the stock transfer completion rate was 56.39%, and the trust beneficiary rights distribution completion rate was 42%.
Evergrande Property is involved in deposit pledge financing. From the end of 2020 to 2021, Evergrande Property provided pledge guarantees for third-party financing through deposits, and the related funds flowed to China Evergrande through the third party. Evergrande Property fully recognized impairment losses of approximately 13.4 billion yuan in 2021.
According to the 2026 interim report of Evergrande Property, the judgments of some recovery cases have come into effect, and as of June 30, it has recovered a total of about 9.5 million yuan.
Due to historical reasons, it is difficult to cut off related transactions between real estate companies and property management companies, but their proportion is decreasing. In the first half of 2026, the proportion of related transaction revenue in Wanwu Cloud has dropped to 4.3%.
A private real estate company insider told the Economic Observer that during the upward trend of the real estate market, real estate companies entrust related businesses to property management companies, which is essentially a blood transfusion for property management companies and facilitates spin off and listing; But as the real estate industry enters a period of adjustment, property management companies are giving back to developers, taking it for granted internally, but they cannot pass the deadline on paper.
From debt repayment to payment collection
In November 2023, Rongwanjia and Rongsheng Development signed the first round of debt redemption framework agreement. Rongwanjia plans to receive 10870 parking spaces and 332 residential, office, and commercial properties, offsetting approximately 568 million yuan in receivables. The development cost of these assets is approximately 918 million yuan, with an assessed value of approximately 576 million yuan.
As of June 18, 2025, Rongwanjia has settled approximately 288 million yuan in accounts receivable, accounting for 50.8% of the planned offset amount. Rongwanjia disclosed that some assets were seized or frozen by government departments or courts after the agreement came into effect, and cannot be transferred. There have been changes in the market sales conditions of some assets, and Rongwanjia refuses to accept them.
During the same period, Rongwanjia sold a total of approximately 9.22 million yuan worth of debt assets, equivalent to approximately 3.2% of the settled debt amount.
In June 2025, Rongwanjia and Rongsheng Development signed a second round of framework agreement, intending to receive 12689 parking spaces, 5479 storage rooms, and 112 residential, apartment, and commercial properties for approximately 1.07 billion yuan, offsetting service fees and project payments. The assets involve 83 projects in Hebei, Jiangsu, Liaoning, Shandong, Chongqing and other places, with some projects under construction at the time of signing contracts.
According to the 2025 annual report of Rongwanjia, its inventory increased from approximately 339 million yuan at the end of 2024 to approximately 742 million yuan at the end of 2025, mainly related to the purchase of real estate and parking spaces.
In July 2023, Ocean Services signed an agreement with related companies of Ocean Group to receive 4961 parking spaces and 168 commercial properties for approximately 626 million yuan, offsetting related receivables. The parking space is priced at approximately 474 million yuan, and the commercial property is priced at approximately 152 million yuan.
On July 16, 2025, COSCO Group announced that COSCO Service plans to return 2684 parking spaces located in the East China region, involving a transfer price of 323.2 million yuan, with a book value of approximately 246 million yuan as of the end of May 2025. Ocean Group stated that the related project companies are involved in litigation, disputes, and unpaid debts, making it difficult for Ocean Services to sell the parking spaces after receiving them.
Both parties agree that after the parking space is returned, the original transfer price will be converted into a ten-year loan provided by Oceanwide Services to the designated enterprise of Oceanwide Group, with an annual interest rate of 2%. According to the agreement, the first repayment of principal is scheduled for the 48th month after the loan is utilized, and some interest can be deferred for payment.
German commercial investment services have also arranged for the return of debt paying parking spaces twice. In December 2023, Deshang Industrial Investment Services plans to receive 1512 parking spaces from affiliated developers for 51.64 million yuan to offset trade receivables. In September 2024, both parties agreed to return 485 parking spaces, with the debtor paying 15.46 million yuan. In October 2025, Deshang Industrial Investment Service returned the remaining 652 parking spaces, with the debtor paying 22.52 million yuan. Two returns of parking spaces account for 75% of the total received quantity.
The property management personnel mentioned above said that in the short term, due to the large amount of provision, the property management company faces significant financial pressure. However, in the long run, in this round of real estate adjustment, the property management company gradually separates from its parent company and begins to develop independently, forcing it to improve its related capabilities and competitiveness, including services.
In their view, property management companies have low profits and make hard-earned money, but due to their stable cash flow, they have become high-quality assets in the present. Previously, when the group held its annual meeting, the CEO of the property management company would sit in the second or third row; now, when the annual meeting is held, the real estate company owners are holding the CEO of the property management company to sit next to them.