How did the Republican Party rise in the United States

2026-11-18 15:59

Liu Zhanxiong | Text

The Rise of American Civilization "was once known for its bold and powerful writing style, which greatly expanded the narrow perspective of traditional historical works. The book attempts to start from an economic perspective and explain the development process of America. Simultaneously viewing cultural history as the history of the entire social life, attempting to present the full picture of America as a 'growing organism'.

The Rise of American Civilization

Charles Beard, Mary Beard

Xu Yafen in Gan | Translated

The Commercial Press

January 2011


Author Charles Beard proposed a concept known as "economic determinism," advocating for the exploration of objectivity, continuity, and regularity in historical development. He opposed the commonly held belief in a "city on a hill." He argued that the establishment of the United States Constitution was not driven by abstract principles of freedom and democracy, but rather by specific interests, and was a struggle among various bondholders to protect their property interests. This viewpoint had a huge impact on the academic community of moral conservatism at that time.

The values of gentry in slave states

On the eve of the civil war, the capitalist economy was in an upward trend, and the attitudes of southern plantation owners were quite complex. They adopted a two faced strategy: on the one hand, they did business with northern industrial and commercial groups, cooperated with each other, and formed a close interest binding; On the other hand, they also promote the gentry lifestyle, criticize the rampant materialism of capitalism and industrialized society, and are full of hostility towards the emerging bourgeoisie.

The sales process of the cotton economy heavily relies on the Yankees (originally a nickname for northerners in the United States, specifically referring to residents in the six states near the Atlantic in the northeast of New England). Northern agents transport cotton from scattered rural plantations to ports, and then arrange for raw cotton to be processed in textile factories. The agent provides a warehouse and undertakes transportation. This upstream and downstream industrial chain is so deeply bound that the Southern Confederacy was declared and separated from the federation. After the economic decoupling between the two sides, thousands of businesses in the North went bankrupt.

The white slave owners relied on Yankee businessmen but looked down upon them. One of the favorite topics in Southern newspapers was mocking the greedy and profit seeking nature of New Englanders. The plantation owner claims to be a gentleman, brave in killing enemies, chivalrous towards women, respectful towards peers, and merciful towards the lower class. They live in palace style mansions, often holding grand social events, and even medieval style horse racing competitions.

They maintain a strong martial spirit, with each slave holding state having its own military academy, and southern youth growing up on horseback. The white upper class society in the South is dominated by the values of "business people are all misers, and Yankees are all misers" and "true gentlemen should rely on the land to make a living, hunt and socialize in daily life".

Some literati simply concocted the "Norman origin theory", believing that their bloodline is noble and can be traced back to the conqueror William, who is not of the same ethnic group as the descendants of the Mayflower. According to this theory, the direct ancestors of Southern white people were the Cavaliers (royalists during the English Civil War), who were expelled from their homeland by Cromwell and migrated to colonies such as Virginia. Going back, it can be traced back to the Norman nobles who occupied Britain in the 11th century, while the ancestors of the New Englanders were the Saxons conquered by William I. A genealogy of "Norman nobility knight party southern estate owner" was shaped.

Scott's novels also played a role in fueling the flames, and his works such as "A Brief History of the Saxon Post Calamity Heroes" praising medieval society were particularly popular in the southern slave states. Before the Civil War, many young plantation workers dressed themselves up as knights in novels. Politician James Hammond passionately claimed, "The slave system actually created a noble class, a talented, moral, generous, selfless, and brave noble class

According to the Norman origin theory, the Northern American society loved to strive and make money precisely because their ancestors were of lower class and did not have an elegant and noble cultural life. Their spiritual world was barren, and their thoughts were all focused on money. A Kentucky editor commented, "The Norman cavalry in the South could not tolerate the vulgarity and recklessness of the Saxon descendants of New England

In the plantation depicted by the slave owning newspapers, the master worked hard to care for the slaves, and the slaves sincerely loved their masters, creating a harmonious social scene. At the same time, they criticized how developed capitalist regions prioritize profit and money. This trend continued to develop, giving rise to the notion that slavery was more "humane" than free employment, believing that Yankee workers were exploited, that prices were high in first tier cities such as New York, and that the grassroots in the employment system were as miserable as slaves in cotton fields.

William Grayson, a literary figure from South Carolina, wrote a long poem titled "The Laborer and the Slave": "The workers are dressed in tattered clothes, the moldy weeds make beds, and the streets and ditches are filled with slaughterhouse sewage to make ends meet." On the other hand, there is no unemployment among black slaves in the South, and they have basic living security. These advocates of slavery demonstrated astonishing 'institutional confidence'.

Three party formations of the right-wing

The emerging force of the Republican Party emerged around the debate on slavery.

Since the founding of the country, the northern bourgeoisie has introduced three political agents, the first of which is the Federalist Party, led by Hamilton, a close aide to the founding father Washington, and the first Secretary of the Treasury. He had a strong pro British sentiment. During the French Revolution, under Hamilton's strong push, the federal government implemented a "one-sided" foreign policy, made peace with London, and entered a "quasi war" state with France.

At that time, over 50% of imported goods in North America were carried by British ships, and 90% of imported goods were produced in the UK. Many patriots believe that the American economy is still a vassal state of Britain, and the War of Independence was in vain? Under the planning of right-wing elites, North America is positioned as a business partner and Protestant brother of London, guarding the British Empire.

This diplomatic attitude ultimately buried the Federalist Party. After the outbreak of the Second Anglo American War, the industrial and commercial groups in the Northeast cut off their trade with the British Empire. In the 1830s, the Whig Party filled the political vacuum by raising the banner of industrial policy and trade protectionism, competing with the Democratic Party. In the two party structure, the Whig Party represents the interests of high net worth individuals, while the Democratic Party emphasizes "dividing the cake" in economic development, claiming to seek welfare for the majority of workers and peasants, while also echoing the racist ideology of lower class white people.

The History of the Democratic Party in the United States has a wonderful commentary: the composition of the top echelons of the two parties is very similar. Among senior public officials and congressmen, the higher the position, the closer Democrats are to Whigs in terms of wealth. However, at the local level, the Democratic Party has clearly become more grassroots. In many states, the Whig Party promotes local leaders from local social elites, while local leaders of the Democratic Party tend to become professional politicians and rely on meager wages to make a living. In terms of religious and racial background, grassroots officials of the Democratic Party often come from disadvantaged groups, either newly arrived foreign immigrants or WASP (White Anglo Saxon Protestants) belonging to lower status denominations.

The governance of the Whig Party has a strong progressive reform color, with activities held at charity dinners and speeches in the upper class, from calling for international disarmament to boycotting small pubs, from promoting compulsory education to abolishing corporal punishment, from fighting for women's rights to stopping the abuse of patients in mental hospitals, and promoting various forms of good governance.

Scholar James MacPherson once calculated the voting data for proposals such as prohibition, prison reform, and increased funding for public schools in seven states (New Hampshire, New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Ohio, Virginia, Alabama, and Missouri). The Whig Party has maintained a good record in the past 20 years since its formation.

However, ordinary grassroots are not enthusiastic about this kind of "suspended" and "artificial" improvement. They prefer the Democratic Party, which has populist undertones and directly criticizes tycoons and large corporations.

What is even more confusing is that Tammany Society (the Democratic Party's headquarters in New York, and in some contexts also refers to the factional forces in the northeast of the Democratic Party) weaves together labor rights and white supremacy racism. They fiercely criticized capitalists for being unkind to the rich and creating panic, claiming that if slaves were liberated, there would be a large influx of black people into industrial cities such as New York, Philadelphia, Boston, and the world would be in chaos. The Democratic Party used this as a counterattack against abolitionism, while also winning over two groups: wealthy plantation owners in the south and the working class in free states.

After the outbreak of the Civil War, this tactic continued, and a pro Southern newspaper issued a voice of hatred towards black people: "Workers! Be careful! Organize and oppose this dangerous factor that will cause you poverty and destruction

Lincoln and other new generation politicians faced head-on, criticizing slavery and the values of the Southern gentry, supplemented by supportive policies such as the Homestead Act, in an effort to win over the blue collar class in the North. They emphasized that the United States is a country with high social mobility, and workers can turn the tide as long as they are diligent. Regardless of whether they are poor or rich, Yankee people follow Protestant ethics such as self-discipline, moderation of pleasure, and hard work.

Many abolitionists criticize slavery precisely because the enslavement system corrupts the moral outlook on labor. As physical labor is associated with black slaves, labor is considered lowly rather than honorable, and even white labor is not respected. The media in the Free State stated that increasing wages and improving social status as incentives are far more effective in motivating a person's work enthusiasm than whips.

A large number of young white people voted with their feet and migrated from slave states to free states in search of opportunities. The number of people migrating in this direction is twice that of those migrating from north to south.

Magazines that defend slavery and promote the superiority of plantation owners and gentry should also be published in the North. One of the public opinion strongholds of cotton interest groups is the Debao Review, where publisher James Debao's hometown of New Orleans did not even have printing equipment and had to send it to New York for printing. During the distribution period, three-quarters of the advertising revenue of Debao Review came from companies in the Northern Free State.

The enslavement of black people contradicts the idea of freedom and equality for all, which naturally leads to the possibility of inequality within white people. Theorists such as South Carolina judge William Harper claim that humans are "born submissive" and that it is in the "order of nature and God" that those who possess advanced abilities, knowledge, and power should control and dispose of those who are inferior. This greatly violates the equal values of blue collar workers in the north.

The elite class in the southern region claimed to have inherited the Norman knights and the British royalists, exuding an air of superiority and failing to attract the favor of the descendants of the Mayflower (the New England states were the headquarters of the Puritans).

In the battle against slave owning groups, a local small party called the Republican Party emerged. It was centered around former Whig Party members such as Lincoln and William Seward (Secretary of State during the Civil War), and also absorbed some Northern Democrats who felt that the party's leadership was too biased towards the cotton industry economy, so they changed their flag.

The Republican Party's Victory in the North

As an emerging political party founded only three or four years ago, the Republican Party's path forward has not been smooth sailing. In the 1856 election, the Republican Party received over 1.34 million popular votes and 114 electoral votes, significantly lagging behind the Democratic presidential candidate. Buchanan received over 1.83 million popular votes, giving him an advantage of nearly 500000 votes.

In the 1860 election, the Republican campaign headquarters focused their efforts on swing states such as Illinois, and took advantage of the split of their opponent, the Democratic Party (which split into two presidential candidates due to the issue of slavery, Douglas and Breckenridge), to "narrowly but steadily" win the White House. Lincoln won the overall election with less than half of the national popular vote.

The Civil War was both a danger and an opportunity, and with the immortal achievement of defending federal unity, Lincoln's party completely stabilized the rear.

In the difficult years of war, the ruling party encountered several setbacks. On the eve of the 1864 presidential election, the war weariness in the north reached its peak, and the common people felt tired of the war. Fortunately, the military victory on the front line injected a shot of adrenaline into the election a month later. Sherman won in the Georgia battlefield and Sheridan won in the Shenandoah Valley battlefield. Lincoln narrowly escaped danger and won re-election.

After the dust settled on Appomattox (where Robert Lee admitted defeat, marking the end of the Civil War), the undeniable victory turned into a huge political dividend, benefiting the Republican Party.

The Democratic Party has been completely relegated to another register due to the traitor stain of the pro Southern Alliance. The 'blood stained speech' is the most effective way for right-wing politicians to mobilize the masses. The speakers usually have experience serving in the Northern Army or are staunch advocates of war. They wave their military uniforms and shirts, which have been bloody on the battlefield, while discussing current affairs and criticizing the enemy party.

In a speech in 1866, Indiana Governor Oliver Morton said, "Every unrepentant rebel is a Democrat. Every soldier, every deserter, every coward who evades conscription is a Democrat... Every person who has contributed to the rebellion in this war, every person who has killed federal prisoners of war with abuse and hunger, and every person who plots to provoke a civil war in a state loyal to the Union is a Democrat." From General Grant to the end of the 19th century, all presidential candidates nominated by the Republican Party, except for one, have served as officers in the Union Army.

By providing large pensions, the Republican Party and the grassroots of the Yankees have achieved a binding interest. The Civil War was a general war, and most of the men who were suitable for the battlefield were mobilized. The veterans' relief fund was equivalent to a disguised national welfare system, and successive Republican parties used it to win over the lower class of Yankees.

Due to the imperfect implementation of the system, many disabled people were not injured during the civil war, but were able to obtain this special subsidy and eat this financial meal through deception or backdoor channels. In his first presidential term, Democratic Cleveland vetoed a bill to increase pension benefits, stating, "The money allocated by the state for subsidies should be used to compensate those who have suffered losses in defending the federal government and serving the country and cannot live independently. They have the right to receive government relief

This measure sparked a strong backlash and confirmed the prejudice of the Yankees against the "rebel party". A pastor summarized the Democratic Party as "rum party, Catholic party, and rebel party". The vote machine of the 'Republic Army' is in operation, bringing Cleveland down in the next election. This is the organization of retired veterans of the Northern Army, one of the largest pressure groups outside the hospital. Behind every veteran vote is a family and a community network, so the political energy of the "Republic Army" is enormous. Around 1890, it had about 400000 members and fully covered northern towns.

The bloody speeches, combined with the real gold and silver of pensions, made the Republican regionalism mobilization invincible. In most elections in the mid to late 19th century, Michigan, Wisconsin, and Minnesota, the three northern states, were the Republican Party's stronghold.

After firmly controlling the political power, the economic proposition of the "Big Boss Party" was able to be implemented again. In 1867, after the end of the Civil War, Secretary of State Seward was eager to expand maritime trade and bought Alaska from Russia. At that time, people generally believed that buying Alaska was a big loss and gave Russia an advantage. Small farmers and cotton plantation owners in the inland United States lack an international perspective and are not interested in expanding overseas. Many years later, it was discovered that the US side found a big bargain in this business.

The Gilded Age was accompanied by gunboat diplomacy, which was driven by the interests and demands of the northern industrial and commercial groups. They focus on global strategic layout to safeguard commercial interests. In terms of domestic affairs, the three pillars of industrial policy are unimpeded, and political barriers to railway and canal infrastructure projects no longer exist. According to the tradition since the founding of the country, each state has strong independence and is responsible for its own finances and economy. The construction and operation of railways are often cross state commerce, involving a series of troubles. However, the Civil War completely shattered the supremacy of state power. The Lincoln government promoted the construction of the Pacific Railroad and allocated a large amount of cheap land, along with construction land allocated to other railway companies, totaling 120 million acres.

In 1860, on the eve of the Civil War, the northern society had strong economic potential, with much more railways in the Free States than in the South. The 11 states of the Confederate States accounted for less than 30% of the total railway miles in the country; Most of the inventors of paper machines, harvesters, and other technologies are Yankees; Blue collar workers in free states are also of higher quality, generally receiving compulsory education, with an overall literacy rate of 89%, and the per capita circulation of newspapers and magazines for Yankees is twice that of the southern United States.

In the second half of the 19th century, the federal government actively cooperated with major bankers, implemented protective tariffs, and the industrialization of the North entered the fast lane, entering the golden age of "blooming flowers and cooking oil".