
Introduction
A design company with a scale of two hundred people, the model is responsible for exhaustive planning, the partners finalize the direction, and the director makes the final review. The enterprise's profits have doubled, and the only items that can be priced by the accounting system are computing power procurement and algorithm research and development investment. The value of making directional judgments and final decisions cannot be found in corresponding accounting subjects, without contract terms and clear considerations. This is not rhetoric, it is a bookkeeping problem that is right in front of us.
In the preface article of "Carbon Silicon Symbiosis Economics", we clarified how symbiosis occurs, how interfaces are translated, how time generates friction, how decisions are co created, and so on; As the final chapter of the series, this article aims to make the final cut: how to value the carbon based contribution of carbon silicon joint production.
The primary dilemma faced by distributive justice in the AI era is that joint output continues to expand, while contributions that can enter the distribution ledger and be accounted for continue to shrink. The market naturally allocates increment to the easily quantifiable party, while judgment, aesthetics, responsibility, and decision-making power are precisely difficult to measure with numbers.
Next, we need to answer two questions: which parts of carbon based contributions can be priced and how to price them; What do those invaluable contributions rely on to sustain their survival.
1、 Ownership should not only be written as' to whom ', but also as' how to divide'
1.1 Three layer ownership: How can carbon based contributions be priced separately?
At the legal level, ownership is never a complete ownership, but a bundle of rights that can be divided and priced separately. In the carbon silicon co production scenario, it can be divided into at least three layers.
The first layer, the creative direction belongs to carbon based. The moment of realizing potential risks is the starting point of joint production, which cannot be priced in advance and can only realize profits afterwards.
At the second level, the scheme exhaustively lists the attributed computing power and algorithms. Corresponding to capital returns, calculable, divisible, and eligible for securitization.
The third layer, the final veto power belongs to the human executing end. The moment of saying 'this is it' or 'no, regenerate' is both a node of meaning injection and a node of responsibility assumption. Having the power of suspension (also known as the veto power in the following text), one should receive corresponding benefits. Calling for suspension is not a consolation reward, but a consideration for taking risks.
1.2 Why Cannot Buy Out: A Minimal Example
How to determine the proportion between the three layers of equity and whether they can be combined and held? The proportion itself is not important -25, 55, 20 are just indicative, what is important is the structural constraint. Assuming that the annual net income of a joint output is 100 units, the baseline allocation plan is creative direction 25, computing algorithm 55, and final rejection 20. The same entity that undertakes both creative direction and final review work can merge to obtain 45 units of revenue, but the corresponding 20 units for final review must retain loss exposure and cannot be converted into fixed revenue linked to output.
The premium of final appeal power is essentially a pricing for the "disappearance of reversibility": when the decision is irrevocable, the veto power generates positive rent; Buying out veto power is equivalent to externalizing the risk of irreversible decisions. The three-tier rights cannot be bundled and bought out at once: it is allowed for the same entity to merge creative direction and final review, but the final review share cannot be absorbed by the equity agreement as a whole. Buying out is precisely the risk; Once the risk is bought away, the parties lose the motivation to raise objections, and the shutdown system is the safety valve of the entire system.
We need to be wary of the "nodding final review": simply clicking on the screen to confirm can be considered as manual review at the legal level, but its value tends to be zero at the institutional level. If the rules cannot distinguish between substantive review and simple confirmation, the three-layer ownership will degenerate into two layers. How does this' nodding final review 'erode the safety valve? The second section will provide corresponding tax constraints.
The rule of dividing the cake determines who is still willing to stay at this table.
2、 Algorithm tax: The tax base is not 'how much AI is used', but 'how deep it is replaced'
2.1 Taxable substitution amount: based on the depth of substitution as the tax base
Behind the efficiency dividends brought by pure substitution AI, there are hidden social costs that no one can bear: interrupted income for workers, continuous depreciation of skills, and disintegration of existing social relationships. This is similar to factory emissions, where companies enjoy cost dividends and society bears negative consequences, thus requiring tax regulation.
The 'robot tax' has long been hindered by the difficulty of defining the tax base. Taxation based on the scale of AI usage will indirectly punish technological progress; According to alternative deep taxation, there are also difficulties in quantification. The following formula is not a text of financial and tax legislation, but a system diagram that turns "substitution depth" into an observable variable.
Taxable substitution amount=Business line output x (Benchmark labor ratio - Effective labor ratio)
The lower limit of the difference is zero: business lines with a higher proportion of manual labor than the benchmark will not be subject to negative tax. Two additional calibers need to be explained. Firstly, for AI native businesses that have not had human labor since their establishment, the formula does not calculate "replacement costs", but rather "relative benchmark labor gaps". Legislative expressions should truthfully use the latter concept to avoid discrepancies between the name and reality of the tax base. Secondly, the proportion of benchmark manual labor is not fixed and should be regularly reassessed and announced with the process of industry intelligence, otherwise the tax base will automatically evaporate with the diffusion of technology.
The proportion of benchmark labor is uniformly announced based on industry and job category. The proportion of effective manual labor does not accept self reporting by enterprises, and only four types of verifiable evidence are recognized: decision log retention rate, final review actual modification range, sampling and review problem rate, and manual intervention records generated by the system trace that can be cross verified with social security and personal income tax data. To prevent companies from diluting evidence by independently accounting for high labor business lines, it is recognized that all accounting will be consolidated on a legal entity basis.
Distinguish three tax rates based on evidence: business lines with real traces of human-machine collaboration enjoy tax reductions; If only personnel are on duty and there is a lack of substantial modification records, the tax shall be levied according to the benchmark tax rate; The "nodding final review" business that is directly approved by all staff without modification shall be subject to the highest tax rate. Tax differentials do not penalize technological substitution itself, but only constrain the withdrawal of manual labor at critical nodes that require trust and irreversible consequences.
Taking customer service centers as an example, AI undertakes most of the consulting work, but complex complaints still require manual intervention; If we simply pursue cost reduction and eliminate manual labor at the dispute resolution stage, it will ultimately increase the risk of complaint escalation, which is exactly the scenario that needs to be constrained.
2.2 Tax Destination and Institutional Hedge
There are two main purposes for tax revenue. One is the national basic computing power quota. The access capability in the digital age is gradually approaching the importance of literacy rate and belongs to the basic digital public goods. The second is to provide transitional funds to support replaced workers in learning how to review models, exercise veto power, and inject value judgments into the system, rather than simply learning programming.
In response to common doubts in academia, a matching hedging mechanism is needed: prioritizing the binding of the tax base to the total salary of the replaced positions, setting exemption amounts and progressive gradients to alleviate tax burden shifting; Faced with the arbitrage space brought by cross-border AI service deployment, identify taxable business based on the actual delivery location of the service and the ownership location of the beneficiary data, and block the arrangement of "book offshore and business onshore"; At the management level, there is no need to establish new institutions, and cross verification of existing social security, personal income tax, and working hour data can be relied upon to complete the verification.
3、 Don't divide the data into individual parts, give it portability first
3.1 Breaking Out of Individual Sharing: Path to Public Data Fund
The platform advocates that data is self cleaned and processed, while users believe that data comes from their own behavior, and there is a misalignment of the focus of the debate between the two sides. What truly has long-term value is not the original behavior log, but the preference profile and trust relationship formed by long-term trajectory precipitation.
Directly deriving the principle of "dividing data into users by piece" will encounter engineering bottlenecks. The large model relies on massive trajectory joint training, and the marginal contribution of a single user trajectory approaches zero. Dividing individuals into Shapley values (a method of measuring individual marginal contributions in cooperative games) is essentially difficult to solve, and it is not feasible at the practical level.
A more practical path is to transform the allocation dimension: dividing revenue according to data categories and time slices; Establish a public data fund, with the platform paying fees based on data categories and business scale. The funds will be used for data trust operations, digital literacy promotion, and digital access subsidies for vulnerable groups.
It should be noted that the data fund payment in this section is different from the algorithm tax base in the second section - one is tied to the data scale and category, and the other is tied to the depth of substitution - and the purpose is also separate, which does not constitute duplicate collection; If the legislation wishes to simplify, the two can be merged into two directions of a digital regulation tax.
3.2 Boundaries of Portability: Summary of Standardized Portraits
Compared to direct sharing, data portability is more fundamental. Users have the right to take away their long-term data trajectories and migrate them to other systems. Even if one cannot obtain economic benefits, at least they have the right to make their own choices. Article 20 of the EU General Data Protection Regulation, the EU Data Act, and Article 45 (3) of China's Personal Information Protection Law have all established relevant regulatory frameworks.
The right of portability has clear boundaries. The ten-year data trajectory often contains related information such as communication records and group photos of others, and direct migration can easily lead to privacy breaches. The migration content should be limited to standardized portrait summaries, interface standards should be uniformly published by regulatory authorities, and data usage should be implemented with graded authorization.
At the same time, we must be vigilant: the more standard and dehydrated the abstract, the lower the transfer value, and the portability right will become an "empty right" that the platform likes to see. For this purpose, a minimum information content requirement should be established, and the dimensions that must be included in the abstract should be clearly defined by regulatory standards; The information involving others in the trajectory should be anonymized as a principle, rather than being excluded from the portable range as a whole. The goal of portability is to break platform lock-in, rather than creating new risks of information leakage.
4、 Bottom line is not a slogan, we need to be able to decide on a solution
4.1 Carbon based well-being: the line drawn before cutting the cake
The three levels of ownership, algorithm tax, and data rules all ultimately have to undergo the same test: in ten years, can an ordinary person who does not engage in code development or technical architecture work live a decent life?
If the answer is negative, this system cannot be simply evaluated as inefficient, but as a complete failure. Welfare distribution cannot wait for the cake to grow before it is redistributed. By the distribution stage, the pattern of interests has already solidified.
The bottom line of welfare should be transformed into a list of feasible veto powers: basic housing, basic healthcare, skills transfer support, minimum transitional income, while ensuring job seeking, credit, public services, judicial evaluation and other scenarios, which cannot be unilaterally monopolized by automated decision-making. The "skill transformation support" and the second section of the transformation fallback funds point to the same thing: the funding is on the tax side, and the inventory is on the power side, forming the same bottom line together.
4.2 Main body of marking and quantification trap
The bottom line should be determined by the legislative body as the overall framework, with an independent expert committee drafting a list and regularly publicly revising it. The power to draw lines cannot be handed over to the administrative department being assessed, otherwise the bottom line will continue to drift along with the assessment indicators.
We need to avoid a trap here: welfare is difficult to fully quantify, but it also needs to be verifiable. Distinguish between two types of quantification methods: threshold testing only determines whether the standard is met, without setting continuous bonus points; The bottom line clause only has veto power and does not have additional items. It cannot be linked to departmental budgets or performance evaluations. The bottom line of well-being is not a coefficient in the objective function, but a prior constraint of the objective function itself. Measuring well-being aims to hold the bottom line; Once well-being is written into the objective function, it means handing over the bottom line. Read with a thermometer, don't use it as a KPI.
Who is responsible when the bottom line is broken is the next question - the answer is given in the fifth section.
5、 The ultimate outcome of carbon based computing is not faster than that of silicon-based computing
5.1 Three remaining tasks
Carbon based will gradually discover that the vast majority of its computing power will be covered by AI. This is not scary. The story of humans and mammoths is not so much about winning in running speed as it is about winning in storytelling, collaboration, and the ability to give meaning to things.
The core work of future humans will shrink into three things: setting goals for the system and determining what AI should pursue; Exercise veto power at critical nodes; Maintain a life that is not continuously optimized by algorithms. The three-tier institutional design mentioned earlier precisely protects the first two tasks. These two items can be priced, which happens to be the core business that distinguishes humans from machines.
Among the three tasks, the first two are directly priced and protected by the three-tier ownership. The third item - maintaining a life that is not continuously optimized by algorithms - cannot be priced, nor does it need to be priced: it is supported by the bottom line list in Section 4 and the national basic computing power quota in Section 2. At this point, the first two questions each have their own destination: those that can be priced have entered the ownership structure, while those that cannot be priced are maintained by the bottom line and quotas.
5.2 Accountability Chain: Defend every objective function rewrite
This article does not make an absolute judgment on whether machines can complete the above tasks in the future. But under the existing computing paradigm, there is currently no matching responsibility mechanism. Simply emphasizing that 'decisions must be made by living people' is too narrow, and humans will also be incentivized and distorted. A more secure solution is to build a complete accountability chain: two people sign a panel, set up independent veto seats, implement term rotation, leave a trace of the entire operation, and implement accountability. What the system needs to protect is not a single natural person, but to ensure that every adjustment of the objective function can be traced back to the responsible subject who has the authority and dares to raise objections.
Conclusion
At this point, the "carbon silicon symbiotic economics" can come to an end. From the proposal of symbiotic relationships, to the gradual development of substitution, collaboration, and pricing, and then to the distribution and conclusion of this article - along the way, this picture is complete: silicon-based is responsible for calculation, carbon based is responsible for meaning, and institutional responsibility ensures that both parties receive their rightful share.
The distributive justice of the AI era does not require empty slogans.
Efficiency is efficiency, bottom line is bottom line;
Silicon based running path, carbon based guarding direction;
Can be calculated clearly, cannot be calculated and held.
The first cut determines who is willing to stay at this table. The cake will continue to grow, but the cutting method determines where the increment of civilization ultimately flows. From symbiosis, interface, time friction to allocation, this line only proves one thing: carbon based is not the old subject that loses to computing power, but the one that continuously rewrites the objective function for computing power. After the final chapter, the economics of carbon silicon symbiosis no longer asks "who replaces whom", but only "whether every goal rewriting can catch up with people".