Chen Chunhua: Positions will not disappear, roles are growing

2026-11-17 15:06

Author's Spring Blossoms

Managers often have the question: With the implementation of AI systems in the company, many repetitive tasks have been replaced. Employees should shift from "doing tasks" to "playing roles", but the more they think about it, the more confused they become - should the finance position still be? Do you still need a compliance position? If all the positions are gone, how do employees know they belong here? If the position is still there, how can the role be put in?


This question raises the key point. Many people think that 'from position to role' means using roles to eliminate positions. But the fact is not like that.


Positions will not disappear, and positions and roles will coexist for a long time


First, answer the most fundamental question: Will positions disappear?


Can't. Positions and roles will coexist for a long time.


Why? Because organizations require a stable foundation for operational order. Cost accounting, compliance review, basic personnel management... These work rules are clear, processes are fixed, and results are predictable. Using positions to support is the most economical and efficient way, as well as the design that is most in line with organizational stability. Positions provide a sense of belonging and predictable career development paths, which cannot be replaced by roles.


But at the same time, in the era of AI, more and more jobs are uncertain - requiring cross departmental collaboration, creative judgment, and adjustment with task changes. This type of work is not suitable to be defined by fixed positions and needs to be carried out by roles.


So, the ideal form for the future is:Position as the bottom, role as the surface.


The relationship between positions and roles is not substitution, but complementarity. Maintain the certainty of the organization's position and capture the growth points of the organization's role.


AI has arrived, and the quality of the job has changed


Since positions will not disappear, what is the impact of AI on positions?


The answer is not 'the position is gone', but 'what has changed for the people in the position'.


In 'Common Sense of Management', I repeatedly emphasized a principle: management is only responsible for performance. In the era of AI, the definition of performance has not changed, but the way performance is achieved has changed. In the past, a person in a position had to personally perform all tasks; Today, AI can undertake the standardized and repeatable parts.


For exampleA financial cost accounting position used to require manual data entry, invoice verification, allocation calculation, and report generation. Today, AI can automatically complete these tasks. But this position has not disappeared - it has just changed from "doing accounting" to "reviewing accounting results, handling exceptions, and optimizing rules". The people on the job have changed from 'executors' to' supervisors, judges, and optimizers'.


This is the "texture" change of the position: the mechanical and repetitive content on the position has been stripped away by AI, but the work that requires judgment, responsibility, and exception handling must still be completed by people.


I always believe that the core judgment of enterprise operation work must be completed by people. Intelligent systems can provide faster and more comprehensive analytical support, but cannot replace judgments on business logic, risk boundaries, and long-term value. What can be replaced is' action ', what cannot be replaced is' judgment' and 'responsibility'. And judgment and responsibility are the fundamental reasons for the existence of a position.


How do positions and roles coexist? A simple framework


Many managers are confused by this question: if positions and roles are still needed, how can they be put together?


It's actually quite simple. The same employee can have bothA PositionAndMultiple Roles。


  • PositionIt's his' anchor '. He belongs to a certain department and assumes stable basic responsibilities, gaining a sense of belonging and career development path.
  • RoleIt's his' sail '. He can play different roles in different projects and scenarios according to the needs of the task, and utilize his expertise and creativity.


For example, a financial personnel. His position is' Cost Accounting Specialist ', responsible for reviewing AI generated accounting reports and handling exceptions on a daily basis. This is his stable responsibility. At the same time, he can play the role of a "project financial advisor" in one of the company's new product projects and a "process optimization expert" in another digital transformation project. This is the coexistence of positions and roles - positions provide stability, roles provide flexibility; Maintain the basic skills of the position and capture the growth points of the role.


How can Ai help with role management?


The transition from position to role, AI is not a barrier, but the most important empowering tool.


In 'Collaborative Symbiosis Theory', I proposed the SDAP management model - scenario, intention, ability, and process. This model happens to be suitable for role management.


Scene:AI can dynamically perceive changes in tasks and automatically identify what roles are needed. When a new project is launched, AI can automatically recommend the required role types and quantities based on project characteristics, rather than waiting for people to write job descriptions.


Desire:AI can help employees discover which roles they are suitable for. By analyzing employees' skills, interests, and historical performance, AI can recommend "roles that you may be suitable to play" and stimulate employees' willingness to take on roles proactively.


AbilityAI can automatically push learning resources and simulate training according to role requirements, helping employees quickly fill in their skill gaps. If an employee wants to play the role of a "project financial advisor" but lacks certain skills, AI can recommend relevant courses, cases, and exercises.


Process:AI can track the performance of characters and provide data support for character evaluation. AI can record and analyze what employees have done, solved problems, and created value in this role, helping organizations understand the contributions of their roles and enabling employees to see their own growth.


What do managers need to do?


In the new pattern of coexistence of positions and roles, the task of managers is not to "design job descriptions", but to "build a role ecosystem". There are three specific things:


Firstly, define the 'capability map' of the role.What roles does the organization need? What abilities are required for each role? This requires managers to define based on business strategy. AI can help with matching, but the power of definition must be in the hands of people.


Secondly, establish a role matching and evaluation mechanism.When the task comes, who is most suitable to play this role? How is the contribution of the character seen and recognized? These mechanisms need to be designed by managers.


Thirdly, create a culture that allows for role switching.Many employees are afraid to take on new roles proactively because they are afraid of failure, being judged, and not doing their job properly. Managers need to take action to tell their teams that playing a role is not an "extra burden", but an opportunity for growth. When a person switches between different roles, their value will be seen, their growth will be recognized, and their contributions will be rewarded.


Three hidden pitfalls of implementing "position+role"


The blueprint of "position based, role oriented" is certainly beautiful, but in the actual implementation of this hybrid system in enterprises, it often encounters huge resistance from traditional management inertia. When building this character ecosystem, managers must avoid the following three "hidden bombs" in advance:


The Great Pit of Profit Distribution: How to Get More with More Work?


The traditional salary system is tightly tied to the "position" - the position grading determines the upper limit of the salary package. When employees break through job boundaries, take on multiple "roles" and create additional value, if the incentive mechanism does not keep up, employees will quickly develop a mentality of "doing more and making mistakes, it's better not to do".


Avoiding pitfalls guide:Organizations must introduce a multi-dimensional dynamic incentive mechanism. The basic salary and benefits are determined by the fundamental principles of the position (ensuring no mistakes are made); The incremental contribution brought by the role is immediately realized through project bonuses, short-term points, or "role allowances". Enable the 'spillover value' of talent to be calculated and rewarded.


The Big Pit of Dual Leadership: Whose Should Employees Listen to?


When a financial personnel (position) simultaneously plays the role of a "financial advisor" (role) in a new product project, they will face the dilemma of "dual reporting". The financial manager (job owner) feels that he is "not doing his job properly", while the project manager (role owner) feels that he is "not investing enough". Once there is a conflict between the schedules of two supervisors, the employees caught in between will experience extreme pain.


Avoiding pitfalls guide:Clear "energy allocation rules" and "conflict arbitration mechanisms" must be established. For example, organizations can explicitly stipulate that employees devote 70% of their energy to maintaining their basic job positions and 30% of their energy to occupying dynamic roles. When there is a personnel conflict between departments, it is arbitrated by a higher-level business leader or a micro HR collaboration committee to relieve employees' psychological pressure.


The Great Pit of Cultural Barriers: Breaking the "Territorial Consciousness" of Departmental Walls


'Positions' often come with natural departmental walls and territorial awareness. Many department heads are accustomed to "covering up output" and "protecting their children", treating team members as their own private assets. If other departments want to call on their own people to play a cross-border role, supervisors often instinctively set obstacles and obstruct them.


Avoiding pitfalls guide:Creating a culture that allows for role switching cannot rely solely on slogans, but requires the use of assessment levers. The senior management needs to include 'delivering and activating cross-border role talents to the organization' in the assessment indicators of department heads. Only by turning the 'departmental wall' into a 'glass wall' can the vitality of talent truly flow between different roles.


7、 From 'position person' to 'role person'


Only by avoiding the quagmire of landing can we truly see the direction of the future. Returning to the question at the beginning. When AI takes on the task of execution, how should employees be positioned?


My answer is not 'the position is gone', but 'people cannot be defined by the position'. Organizations still need positions to ensure stable operation, but employees in each position can and should go beyond their positions and play more roles. When AI takes over executive work, people have the energy to do more valuable things - make judgments, take responsibility, and collaborate in creation.


In the era of AI, the most flexible organization is not the organization with the most positions or roles, but the organization that can integrate job stability and role flexibility together.



(End of this article)